Page 1 of 1

30/01/2017 - "The Valley of Shia'dorle" by Jaunie and Frieza

Posted: 30 Jan 2017, 21:45
by Semfry
Map Title: The Valley of Shia'dorle
Author: Jaunie Perry and Tim "Frieza" Kok
From: Déjà Vu - Gryphon Revisited
Filename: usp-05-jaunie-frieza.unr
Music Files: Moroset.umx




Video Playthrough:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=McBHploi2jM

Synopsis: After getting through a Skaarj base you come across another subjugated village.

Discuss!

Re: 30/01/2017 - "The Valley of Shia'dorle" by Jaunie and Frieza

Posted: 01 Feb 2017, 15:27
by UB_
I still believe this is the overall weakest level of the mappack. No bosses, re-uses the Vortex Rikers' "behind-the-doors" scripted event and overall there's really nothing amazing in terms of visuals. Just nothing that makes it stand out in any way.

Re: 30/01/2017 - "The Valley of Shia'dorle" by Jaunie and Frieza

Posted: 01 Feb 2017, 16:54
by Semfry
A decent town map but it feels lacking in anything to really stand out. Everything is serviceable but it's a pretty standard Nali town, with the main church area feeling like it's straight out of Harobed (not sure if the main room is a straight copy, but it's close enough to feel like it), along with the houses. The base section added by Frieza does handle the transition from the previous map well, but the Vortex Rikers-style event being near identical does stick out. The crates that look like they're out of Wolfenstein or something have always stuck out as kind of immersion breaking too, even if they're technically not (I don't think anyway...). The laser fence can lead to some amusing moments but it's not really much of a factor overall.

Re: 30/01/2017 - "The Valley of Shia'dorle" by Jaunie and Frieza

Posted: 06 Feb 2017, 01:17
by Sat42
Still great classic stuff although yeah the following Shia'dorle maps were more memorable and there's a lot of classic-styled maps in Déjà Vu, so I totally agree with those who say this map doesn't stand out.

Still, apart from the Vortex Rikers-styled scripted sequence which kind of pulls you out (since it's a direct reference really), I'd say the map is immersive enough. Don't know about it being the weakest in the set, but I can't think of another one that would hold that title so fair enough.

Funny how one of the moons became so big in this map :p (I must be the only one who pays attention to that sort of detail - it's like when I saw Mars above Na Pali Haven Redux, it came as quite a bit of a shock the first time round ;) )