Hellscrag wrote: I assume your point is based on the fact that "Bob" is an unusual kind of release.
Yes, this is exactly what I'm getting at. An unusual release such as this which is much substantially different than all other maps on UnrealSP would probably not be taken into consideration if the author did not explicitly publish the map on the site. I guess "The Pure" is just some odd exception.
It all comes down to how much you want the scores to be portrayed as an accurate conclusion to the pack. Honestly, I think UnrealSP could do without any scoring system and just be totally subjective (the way I'd do it), but I think the current system has its strengths in other regards such as organization (the biggest in an objective scheme) and quick oversight (something subjective cannot really do). I'm not saying that UnrealSP review schemes are totally objective, but they are nowhere near totally subjective. A UnrealSP review site that was totally subjective wouldn't bother me at all, and actually I think it would work together as a fit "challenger" to this site. People could get some opinions from that other site and compare here for further in-depth analysis.